Easy creative tips

Cloud-Based Vs Self Hosted LMS A Comprehensive Comparison

Aug 2, 2024

Reader Disclosure

If you go online to search for "How to sell online courses or classes," you'll be flooded by ads for a variety of Learning Management Systems (LMS).

WHAT'S IN THE INSIDE          Toggle

In light of how fashionable online education is and how popular it is, there's no reason to wonder why numerous options are readily available.

But, with the many options, how do you decide which is the right one for you?

It's here that this constantly evolving comparison between cloud-based and self-hosted LMSs can be found. Most importantly, LMSs are divided into the two types.

If you've done the necessary research but are confused about these two, we have the answer for you. In this article, we'll discuss their differences and the best one to whom.

Cloud-hosted LMS vs Self-hosted Comparative Analysis

As both self-hosted and cloud-based LMSs have their perks as well as cons, it all comes to what you want. This is why it's important to take a close look at each component of an LMS to determine the one you prefer.

To save your the time and effort, we've completed some research and then compared couple of key aspects among them.

Easy of Use

 Cloud-based LMS:

Cloud-based LMSs strive to be user-friendly to use, even for those who aren't tech-savvy. It's usually easy. It'll take only a few clicks to get started.

The company you choose as your cloud-based LMS handles upgrades and maintenance. This means that you don't have to worry about how the servers are configured and how to deal with any software problems. As a result, your focus is in creating your perfect course.

 Self-hosted LMS:

In contrast setting up a self-hosted LMS can be a little more difficult. This involves setting up, configuring and regularly maintaining the system's content management, which can be difficult for people who aren't tech-savvy.

Once it's up and running and customized, modifying the LMS is much easier. It's usually worth it because of the customizable features as well as other functions that self-hosted LMSs offer.

 Verdict

Cloud-hosted LMS might be sufficient for those who want to create an LMS with no plan or vision of growth. However, if you're looking for an extended period of growth, opt for the self-hosted option, even though the initial setup process could be difficult.

Security

 Cloud-based LMS:

Security is the most important selling point for cloud-based LMS providers. They take strong security measures, including firewalls, encryption and regularly updated security features. They always comply with the latest industry standards and regulations including GDPR as well as HIPAA.

But, in the end the data you store is your personal information on a third party's server. This can be very private for a large number of individuals.

 Self-Hosted LMS:

With a self-hosted LMS is complete control over the security of your data. It is possible to implement custom security solutions that meet your specific brand's needs.

Based on the product you're selling on your LMS and how much you'd like to put your focus upon security. You'll have every option available in a self-hosted LMS. In the end, there is no need to sacrifice security concerns.

 Verdict

While cloud-based LMS offers strong security features however, the dependence on third-party servers can be problematic for the majority of. For those who want to be on the safe option, choose the safer self-hosted LMS choice.

Overall Control

 LMS Cloud Based

Cloud-based LMS provides only limited access to the software. The majority of the time, you are restricted to the vendor's features and settings. This can restrict customization and flexibility.

It will be difficult to manage data management since you have no control over the data. When you use a cloud-based LMS system, it's often believed that the company controls data and users.

 Self-Hosted LMS

A self-hosted LMS gives you the most control in comparison to cloud-based ones. The software can be customized to meet your exact requirements, connect with other systems, and manage your data so you can provide the best customer service.

This degree of control can help you gain credibility from your customers and also makes the acquisition of more users much easier.

 Verdict

For overall control Self-hosted LMSs are the clear winner. When you have a self-hosted LMS it is possible to fully personalize and control all aspects of your LMS.

All Costs

 LMS that is cloud-based

The initial cost of a cloud-based LMS will typically be lower because it is not necessary to invest in equipment or install infrastructure. However, LMSs that are cloud-based come with ongoing subscription fees, which may increase over time.

A few cloud-based LMSs also charge fees based on the number of users. As the amount of users rises, the cost grows. This can become a problem after a certain period.

So, if you plan in scaling your business or expanding the number of users on your LMS website, using a cloud-based LMS is not the most suitable option.

 Self-hosted LMS

Self-hosted LMSs come with higher costs at the beginning due to the need for server infrastructure, software licences, and setup. But once you have your self hosted LMS operating it won't be required to spend any more money.

It is only necessary to plan for hosting, maintenance and occasional upgrades. These will add up to less than you would have paid for a cloud-based subscription.

 Verdict

For cost-effectiveness the self-hosted LMS often provides better value over time, despite the higher initial investment. It makes them an economical choice for long-term use.

Integration and Flexibility

 Cloud-Based LMS

Cloud-based LMS usually offer seamless integration with the most popular tools and services, but it is possible that you will be restricted to the features that are supported by the provider you choose.

It's the reason you must be cautious about the integration facilities of your chosen cloud-based LMS.

 Self-Hosted LMS

Self-hosted LMS offers extensive integration options. It is possible to incorporate any third-party tool APIs, applications, or even custom solutions as needed. The flexibility lets you build a custom learning environment that is able to meet your specific requirements.

 Verdict

To allow for integration and versatility Self-hosted LMS is the superior choice. The ability to connect with a variety of tools will help you and your LMS in multiple ways.

The benefits of having a self-hosted LMS on WordPress?

WordPress has proved to be a boon for people with creative talents who are not into coding. With its unique drag-and-drop feature coupled with an LMS plugin, you will be able to ensure the best possible experience for your users.

Here are some of the top benefits of self-hosted LMS on WordPress:

Control Over Content

One of the best things of self-hosted LMS is the fact that you are in total control of your content. You can decide on what content to share, how to present it as well as who will be able to access the content.

This degree of control guarantees the course materials are secure and properly managed. Additionally, you can set up particular rules and guidelines to ensure that you follow all applicable laws and policy.

Personalization and Branding

WordPress gives you more ways to change things than any other system, and it is possible to make your LMS be a part of your company's story through every angle.

With a myriad of themes and apps to choose from, it is possible to enhance the user experience for users. By adding specific tools and features into your LMS it will enhance the user experience for the people who use it.

More Integration Options

With a simple integration process with your own self-hosted LMS is able to grow and adapt with your business. Overall, it will never cause you to feel trapped.

A Better Learning Environment

It is possible to make your learning platform more interesting and exciting by taking advantage of the most advanced features available in self-hosted LMS.

These features include videos, quizzes, a progress tracking bar, etc.

Gamification options like badges, leaderboards and other features to keep students engaged and engaged. The overall learning experience will be more beneficial for the students If you opt for the self-hosted LMS platform to teach students.

Best Options for Creating an Self-Hosted LMS

It comes with a wide range of access control as well as content drip, seamless integration with a variety of payment options, which makes it ideal for the monetization of your course and delivering a structured learning experience.

It's not everything the thing that makes an amazing. You can:

  • define and manage detailed access policies to safeguard your content, creating multiple access levels quickly.
  • Plan the introduction of course content over the course of time to ensure that learners remain active and make steady progress.
  • Supports numerous payment gateways, including PayPal and Stripe, for smooth transactions.
  • Completely report on your memberships, transactions, and learner progress, giving you insights to improve your courses.
  • Install the LMS tool quickly and easily with just a few steps.
  • Engage your audience by making it gamified so that your audience is more active.

You can get started with for as low as $179.50/Year. For all pro benefits, you'll have pay $499.50/Year.

MemberMouse

MemberMouse is a flexible and robust WordPress plugin designed to help you create and manage websites for membership. With this LMS, you can protect your content, manage different levels of membership, and connect with other helpful tools.

This plugin is a great example of what it offers:

  • A simple interface for setting up and managing your membership.
  • Advanced protection of content to limit access to your classes.
  • Integration with the most popular payment processors such as Stripe, PayPal, and Authorize.net.
  • Flexible membership options, including free, trial, and paid memberships.
  • Comprehensive reporting that tracks member activity and engagement.

Start by signing up for MemberMouse at a cost of $399 per year. However, if you want to gain access to more options and to have a bigger member base, the cost will increase to $2399 a year.

AccessAlly

AccessAlly is an extensive LMS plugin that works with WordPress which combines the management of memberships, courses design, as well as marketing automation. Alongside these functions AccessAlly LMS provides an impressive community-building feature that most LMSs lack.

For example, here are some AccessAlly capabilities:

  • Design interactive and multimedia-rich classes easily.
  • We offer a wide range of membership levels and subscription plans.
  • Robust community features, including forums as well as member directories to foster engagement and interaction.
  • Advanced analytics and reporting to track the progress of learners and assess learning effectiveness.

AccessAlly pricing starts at $99/month AccessAlly pricing includes additional features and capabilities available in higher-tier plans.

What is the best choice?

While LifterLMS and LearnDash have many useful features, LifterLMS ultimately stands out as the best choice for creating an self-hosted LMS with WordPress. Here's why:

  • Superior Access Control gives you unrivaled control of who has access to your content, allowing for highly customizable membership tiers and the ability to protect your content.
  • Affordable Content Dripping: The ability to drip-feed content makes sure that learners receive information steadily which leads to better retention and engagement.
  • Comprehensive Reporting Comprehensive reports of the number of members, transactions, as well as learner progress give you the information you need to fine-tune and enhance your classes.
  • Easy Monetization seamless integration with several payment gateways lets you easily make money from your courses and manage your transactions.
  • User-Friendly Setup: Despite its sophisticated functions, it's easy to configure and maintain and is accessible users with limited technical knowledge.

Set up a Self-hosted LMS using just 4 easy Steps

Once you've figured out the best way to manage an LMS now is the time to make it happen. However, before we do that, let's just say that this isn't rocket science.

Step 1. Download and install

  • Login into the WordPress dashboard for your site.
  • Go to Plugins> Add New -> Upload
  • Select the .zip file you downloaded earlier

Once you have installed the plugin, be sure to enable the plugin.

If you've successfully activated your WordPress, you'll see menus appearing on the WordPress dashboard.

In within the Settingsmenu, you can configure the basic settings, such as payments gateways, currencies, and payment methods etc.

Step 2: Configure Membership levels

If you're making an LMS, there will surely have multiple levels of membership and has no restrictions regarding this. It is possible to create the number of membership levels you want.

Just go to Membership on the dashboard and select Add New.

You should give your membership an appropriate name, and be sure to pay attention that you have set the type of payment to appear. You can either set an annual, one-time annual, or monthly payment.

If you wish to, you could also include a welcome message to your customers.

Once everything looks good, hit publish, and then your membership will be set up. If you'd like to make multiple memberships, repeat the steps.

Step 3. Upload Your Member-Only Content

Go to Rulesfrom the dashboard, then select Add New. On the next page, you'll find dropdown menus to select the rules you'd like to create.

It is possible to create several membership rules through repeating this process. After you're happy with your rules, click the Save Rule.

Step 4: Create a Pricing Page

The pricing page is a essential element to have on your Membership website to help the potential customers decide which membership plan is perfect for them. The page can also prompt visitors to upgrade to a more expensive option by highlighting it's additional features and advantages.

However, how do you design one?

You can do it as in the event that you're willing to put in the same amount of effort by clicking several times.

For creating a pricing page, click Groups on the dashboard, then select Add New. Give your group a descriptive name, then scroll to the group's Options section:

Then, click the plus (+) icon to include each of your memberships on this page. You can change the order that these plans are displayed by simply dragging and dropping them into place:

Next, choose the theme from the Price Page Theme dropdown. Once you're happy with your results, you can publish the webpage:

Your pricing page must be accessible to all. Be sure to place it on the main menu navigation on the left, at the bottom, or even in the in the sidebar.

If that your pricing page is reachable, prospective customers can always be one click away from signing the contract.

Cloud-Based or Self Hosted LMS? It's a fact that you Know It Already!

Hopefully, this blog was helpful enough to enlighten your about the distinctions between cloud-based and self-hosted LMS, and which one will be best for you. If you're really dedicated to your company and have a greater picture in mind, a self hosted LMS option is exactly the best option for you.

Even though various options are offered, it is the ideal solution for your LMS requirements. From capturing leads for your LMS to granular details about every member's profile, it can assist with every step.

Don't forget to tell us about your experience with various LMS solutions, and what kind you like best.

If you've found this post useful, make sure you follow our page via Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and LinkedIn!

S Showrabh       From writing poetry and short stories to writing technical articles on WordPress as well as running a membership site, plenty of things have changed since Showrabh. What did not change is his passion for writing and wasting time. He enjoys football, music, and cricket. He either spends hours looking at his phone or putting on his headphone and write for many hours. When he's not doing any of the above it is not uncommon to hear him explain how someone can love both cricket and football equally at the same time.